My Father · My Father (Original)
New WorldEverydayMy Father No. 1
The robusto that launched the García family's own brand — a 5.2 x 52 Ecuador Habano Rosado smoke full of cedar, cream and gentle spice.
The short answer
The My Father No. 1 is a richer, medium-to-full smoke — a Nicaragua robusto with a Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper. Expect cedar, cream, and black pepper. Critics rate it 94/100.
Flavor profile
Earthy · Creamy · Spice · Sweet · Roast
Critic ratings
Cigar Aficionado
2009
94/100
Scores as published by each reviewer. Casa DNC aggregates third-party ratings; we don't score cigars ourselves.
The verdict
The My Father No. 1 is a richer, medium-to-full smoke from My Father's My Father (Original) line. It's a Nicaragua (New World) robusto wrapped in Ecuadorian Habano Rosado at 5.2 in × 52.
On the palate, expect cedar, cream, and black pepper, leaning earthy. Plan on roughly 60 minutes from light to nub.
It's well regarded: Cigar Aficionado rated it 94/100 in 2009. It pairs naturally with espresso and aged rum. If you're newer to cigars, work up to this one rather than starting here.
The original My Father line is the cigar José "Pepín" García and his son Jaime made to honor their family name, and the No. 1 is the robusto-sized anchor of the lineup. At 5.2 x 52 it's a touch longer than a classic robusto, wrapped in a silky reddish-brown Ecuadorian Habano Rosado leaf over all-Nicaraguan binder and filler.
What it tastes like
Expect that signature García profile: lots of polished cedar, a creamy backbone, and a measured peppery spice on the retrohale, with cocoa and toasted nuts filling in the middle. It sits at medium-full — there's real body and a peppery kick up front that settles down, but it never turns harsh. Construction is excellent, with a slow even burn and a firm, easy draw.
Who it's for
It's a great everyday premium for someone who's moved past mild Connecticuts and wants something with more backbone. Because the whole line is a showcase of Estelí tobacco, it's a perfect reference for our Cuban vs Nicaraguan comparison. New to gauging how bold a cigar will be? Our cigar strength guide helps you read the label.
Light one up after dinner with an espresso, then log it and rate it in the Casa DNC app so you remember how it smoked.
Curious how it stacks up? See Cuban vs Nicaraguan cigars.
My Father No. 1 — frequently asked
- Is the My Father No. 1 a good cigar for beginners?
- Ease into it. The fuller body can be a lot for a first-timer, so it's better once you've built up a little tolerance.
- How strong is the My Father No. 1?
- The My Father No. 1 is Medium-Full-bodied. Strength is about body and nicotine rather than flavor, so eat something first and take it slow if you're sensitive.
- What does the My Father No. 1 taste like?
- Expect cedar, cream, and black pepper, leaning earthy. Tasting notes are a guide — your palate may pick up more or less.
- What is the My Father No. 1's rating?
- Published critic scores: Cigar Aficionado 94/100 (2009). Casa DNC aggregates third-party ratings and doesn't score cigars itself.
- What pairs well with the My Father No. 1?
- It pairs well with espresso and aged rum. As a rule, match the drink's intensity to the cigar's medium-full body.
- How long does it take to smoke the My Father No. 1?
- Plan on about 60 minutes for the robusto — longer if you smoke slowly, which keeps it cool and tasting its best.
More cigars like this
My Father
Medium-FullDon Pepín García Black Label 1979 Robusto
Don Pepín's 'Cuban Classic' Black Label in the 5 x 50 1979 Robusto — a Nicaraguan puro built on Cuban-seed tobacco with earth, cedar and cocoa.
My Father
Medium-FullJaime García Reserva Especial Toro
Jaime García's personal blend in a 6 x 54 Toro — a dark, oily Connecticut Broadleaf over aged Nicaraguan tobacco with cocoa, espresso and cedar.
My Father
Medium-FullMy Father El Centurion Toro
A 6.25 x 52 Nicaraguan puro from the García family under a 3-year-aged sun-grown Criollo wrapper — cedar, a touch of honey, and balanced spice.
My Father No. 1 head-to-head
See how My Father No. 1 stacks up against similar cigars — strength, flavor, and ratings.